Three-way comparison · live

Compare your 3 matched 3PLs.

Side-by-side cost, capability and contract comparison. Set your inputs, choose a preset, see which provider wins on Cheapest, Best fit, or Best long-term.

Get matched yourself → Skip to the matrix ↓
Volume scenario
3,400 orders/mo (your current)
Avg units / order
1.4
Storage pallets
36
Returns rate
12%

What matters to you?

Pick a preset, or customise weights manually.

▸ Customise weights manually Total: 100%
Price40%
Location fit20%
Integrations20%
Reviews / SLA20%
Recommended for you
FulfilPro

Lowest total monthly cost at your volume. Strongest match score (87/100) on your weighted criteria. Open capacity. Sydney-based.

Estimated savings vs current
$1,820/mo

Compared to your current monthly spend of $11,950 (per your audit). Annual: $21,840.

Recoup time
41 days

Switching cost ~$2,500. Recouped from monthly savings inside the first 6 weeks.

Northline
SYDNEY · NSW · 8,400 SQM
eComB2BReturns
ShippingCo
MELBOURNE · VIC · 9,800 SQM
eComWholesaleMulti-state
Pick & packtiered by volume
First pick
Per first item picked per order
$3.95
$13,430/mo
$3.45
$11,730/mo
−$1,700
$3.75
$12,750/mo
−$680
Additional pick
Per additional item, same order
$0.95
$1,294/mo
$0.80
$1,088/mo
−$206
$0.85
$1,156/mo
−$138
Storageper pallet, per month
Pallet storage
Includes ambient + standard rack
$32
$1,152/mo
$28
$1,008/mo
−$144
$26
$936/mo
−$216
Receivingper inbound pallet
Inbound receiving
~12 pallets/mo at your volume
$35
$420/mo
$30
$360/mo
−$60
$32
$384/mo
−$36
Shippingblended rate, your destination mix
Cost-plus model
Carrier rate + markup
$11.20
$38,080/mo
⚠ Cost-plus 14% markup
$10.40
$35,360/mo
−$2,720
$10.95
$37,230/mo
−$850
Hidden feesoften forgotten
Total hidden fees
Account mgmt + returns + integration + LTS
$885/mo
⚠ Photo-on-receive enabled
$520/mo
−$365
$640/mo
−$245
⚠ LTS trigger 60 days
Total monthly
All-in, at your volume
$13,381
$160,572 / yr
$10,476
$125,712 / yr
$12,506
$150,072 / yr
Match score
Your weighted criteria
72 / 100
87 / 100
78 / 100
Pick this 3PL

Pre-signing checks & risk flags

Northline

✓SLA 4h response. Confirmed in writing.
!Cost-plus 14% shipping markup. Negotiate down or pass-through.
×Auto-renew 24 months. Notice period 90 days. Push for 12 months.
!Photo-on-receive billed per-SKU. Worth $48/mo. Disable if not needed.

FulfilPro

✓Tiered pricing locked. Tier 2 at 2k+ orders confirmed.
✓Pass-through shipping. Carrier rate + $0.40 admin fee.
✓12-month term. 60-day exit notice.
!Min monthly $8,500. You'll exceed easily but verify in seasonal lulls.

ShippingCo

✓Lowest pallet rate. $26 — 7% below market median.
×Long-term storage trigger 60 days at 1.5x. Aggressive for slow-mover SKUs.
!Melbourne-based. Outbound to Sydney customers adds 1 day transit.
!Integration fee $2,200. One-off. Negotiate down for long-term commitment.

Need help deciding? Book a 15-min call with Jackson.

Download as PDF Book decision call →